The short answer. For a family wishlist where people can claim gifts without spoiling the surprise, use Giftster, which is free and works with any store. For the gift ideas you spot in Reels, TikToks, and screenshots long before you know where to buy them, use Tote, which keeps those finds searchable but is not a wishlist app. Elfster is the pick for Secret Santa. GoWish and Giftful are good universal wishlists, and Moonsift adds price-drop alerts.
Disclosure: Tote makes this page, and Tote is one of the apps listed. We have no affiliation with the other apps. We checked each app's price, platforms, and features against its own website and US App Store listing on November 19, 2026.
Wishlist and gift idea apps compared
| App | Price (US) | Platforms | Guests can claim gifts | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Giftster | Free | iPhone, iPad, Android, Chrome extension | Yes, hidden from the list owner | Family gift lists and Secret Santa draws |
| Elfster | Free | iPhone, Android, web, Chrome extension | Not described in its listing | Secret Santa for groups of 3 to 300 or more |
| GoWish | Free | iPhone, iPad, Android, web | Yes, hidden from the list owner | One wishlist for any store, shared with friends |
| Giftful | Free | iPhone, iPad, Android, Chrome extension | Yes, hidden from the recipient | Wishlists and registries with price tracking |
| Moonsift | Free; Pro $6 a month | iPhone, iPad, Android, web, Chrome extension | Yes; guests need no account | Wishlists with price-drop alerts |
| Amazon Lists | Free with an Amazon account | Amazon app and website | Purchased items stay hidden from you by default | Gifts that all come from Amazon |
| Tote | Free download; Tote Pro $29.99 a year | iPhone, iPad, web, Chrome | No | Gift ideas you spot in Reels, TikToks, and screenshots |
All the dedicated wishlist apps here are free. Tote Pro is $29.99 a year after a 3-day free trial.
Giftster: best for families
Giftster lets you add items from any store or website and share lists inside private family groups. Shoppers mark items as reserved or bought, and the list owner never sees it. You can manage lists for kids, quietly suggest gifts for someone else's list, and run a Secret Santa draw. It is free on iPhone, iPad, and Android, with a Chrome extension.
Elfster: best for Secret Santa
Elfster draws names for groups of 3 to more than 300, with exclusions for couples, kids, and last year's matches, and sends invites by text or email. Wishlists take items from any store, gift cards, and experiences. Its listing says it is 100% free.
GoWish and Giftful: universal wishlists
GoWish adds wishes from any online store through the iPhone share menu or a pasted link. Guests reserve wishes, and other guests see the reservation while the list owner does not. Giftful works the same way, adds registries, and compares and tracks prices across retailers. Both are free.
Moonsift: price-drop alerts
Moonsift saves any product from any site, alerts you when prices drop, and lets guests mark gifts as bought without making an account. Unlimited wishlists are free, and Pro is $6 a month.
Amazon Lists
If every gift comes from Amazon, a shared Amazon list is enough. Its Don't spoil my surprises setting is on by default, so gifts people buy keep showing as unpurchased to you.
Tote: for gift ideas before they are products
Many gift ideas show up as a Reel of a pottery class, a TikTok of a gadget, or a screenshot of a friend's story, with no shop link. Tote saves those posts, reads what is in them, and lets you group them into a list per person, so you can search “mom” or “ceramics” when a birthday comes up. It has no gift claiming, so when you are ready to share a wishlist, move the final picks to one of the apps above. The gift idea guide shows how.
FAQ
What is the best wishlist app?
Giftster is the best pick for families: it is free, takes items from any store, and lets shoppers claim gifts without the list owner seeing. For gift ideas you spot in Reels, TikToks, and screenshots before you know where to buy them, use Tote. GoWish and Giftful are strong universal wishlists, and Moonsift adds price-drop alerts.
Which wishlist app stops people buying the same gift twice?
Giftster, GoWish, Giftful, and Moonsift let guests mark a gift as claimed or bought, and keep that hidden from the list owner. Amazon hides purchased items from the list owner by default when buyers are signed in.
What is the best app for Secret Santa?
Elfster runs Secret Santa draws for groups of 3 to more than 300, with exclusions for couples and last year's matches. Giftster also has a Secret Santa drawing.
Can I keep gift ideas from TikTok and Instagram in a wishlist app?
Wishlist apps save products from shop pages. A gift idea you spot in a Reel or TikTok often has no product link yet. Tote saves the post itself, reads it, and lets you find it again when it is time to buy.
Are wishlist apps free?
Giftster, Elfster, GoWish, Giftful, and Amazon Lists are free. Moonsift is free with an optional Pro plan.